# India's Bar Council Drops Inquiry into NALSAR Graduates After Widespread Backlash

*News · World Desk · Published 2026-08-14T05:48:12Z*

Canonical: https://amk.news/article/india-s-bar-council-drops-inquiry-into-nalsar-graduates-after-widespread-backlas

> The Bar Council of India withdrew its order to bar enrolment of NALSAR University's 2026 law graduates and halted the investigation into a student protest over the Chief Justice's convocation invitation. The reversal follows sharp criticism from legal scholars, students and the university’s leadership.

## Key points

- The Bar Council of India announced on Tuesday that it is dropping the inquiry launched against the 2026 batch of NALSAR University of Law graduates.
- Bar Council of India Chairman Manan Kumar Mishra issued a notice on 18 May directing NALSAR University of Law to conduct an inquiry into the student conduct.
- The Bar Council of India rescinded the temporary freeze on the enrolment of NALSAR University of Law 2026 graduates as advocates following widespread criticism.

The Bar Council of India (BCI) announced on Tuesday that it is dropping the inquiry it had launched against the 2026 batch of NALSAR University of Law graduates, after a wave of criticism from the legal community and student body. The council also rescinded the temporary freeze on the enrolment of those graduates as advocates, effectively ending the disciplinary saga that began with a student protest over the invitation of Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant to the university's convocation.

## Background of the convocation controversy

NALSAR, one of India's premier law schools, invited CJI Surya Kant to serve as the chief guest at its May 2024 convocation. A segment of the student cohort objected, arguing that the judiciary should not be given a ceremonial platform that could be perceived as endorsing the institution. The protest escalated into a public dispute, prompting the BCI—India's statutory regulator of the legal profession—to intervene.

## BCI's initial directive and the ensuing backlash

On 18 May, BCI Chairman Manan Kumar Mishra issued a notice directing NALSAR to conduct an inquiry into the conduct of the 2026 batch. The council also issued an unprecedented directive that "no NALSAR 2026 graduate will be enrolled as an advocate," effectively barring the entire cohort from practising law pending the outcome of the probe. The move was reported by several outlets, including *The Times of India* and *Hindustan Times*, and sparked immediate outcry.

Legal scholars, senior advocates and student groups condemned the order as a disproportionate response. Critics argued that the BCI was punishing an entire graduating class for the actions of a minority of protesters and that the council had overstepped its constitutional remit. *The News Minute* quoted a student who said he feared a “shadow ban” if the inquiry proceeded.

_Manmohan Singh being presented a memento by the Chairman, Bar Council of India, Shri Manan Kumar Mishra at the Golden Jubilee Celebrations of Bar Council of India, in New Delhi. The Union Minister for Law & Justice (Image: Wikimedia Commons)_

> "We have decided to close the proceedings altogether," BCI Chairperson Manan Kumar Mishra told reporters, according to Moneycontrol.com.

## NALSAR's institutional response

The university’s vice‑chancellor, who declined to endorse the BCI‑mandated inquiry, said NALSAR would place the council’s directive before its Executive Council for deliberation and would only proceed with a probe if it was permissible under university statutes. This stance was echoed in statements to *The Hindu* and *Bar and Bench*, which noted that the Executive Council would decide whether the BCI’s order aligns with the institution’s regulations.

Following the BCI’s reversal, *Live Law* reported that the council clarified that “the majority of the students were not involved in the CJI invite row,” a rationale also cited by *opindia.com*. The BCI’s swift withdrawal of the enrolment freeze, within hours of the backlash, was highlighted by *The Federal* and *NewsGram*, which described the decision as a “walk‑back” of the earlier ban.

## Implications for legal governance and academic autonomy

The episode underscores the delicate balance between professional regulation and academic freedom in India. While the BCI is empowered to maintain standards of conduct for aspiring advocates, its attempt to discipline an entire graduating class raised questions about due process and the scope of its authority. The university’s pending decision by its Executive Council will likely set a precedent for how higher education institutions respond to external regulatory pressures.

_D.V. Sadananda Gowda addressing the Lawyer's Meet 2015, organised by the Bar Council of India in association with Bar Council of Tamil Nadu and Puducherry, in Chennai on July 25, 2015 (Image: Wikimedia Commons)_

Observers note that the incident arrives at a time when Indian institutions are increasingly under scrutiny for handling dissent. The BCI’s reversal may be read as a retreat in the face of civil‑society resistance, but it also leaves unresolved the broader issue of whether a regulatory body can compel a university to investigate political expression among its students.

As the matter recedes from the headlines, the legal community will be watching closely how the BCI recalibrates its oversight mechanisms, and whether NALSAR’s Executive Council will issue a formal position on the permissibility of such inquiries under university law.

---
Source: AMK News (https://amk.news). Reuse requires attribution and a link to the canonical URL.