# The Precision Trap: Why Highly Consistent Measurements Can Still Be Wrong

*Science · Science Desk · Published 2026-11-18T23:40:25Z · Updated 2026-11-18T23:50:12Z*

Canonical: https://amk.news/article/the-precision-trap-why-highly-consistent-measurements-can-still-be-wrong

> Scientific history is marked by instances where hyper-precise measurements led to incorrect conclusions, from the Hubble Space Telescope's flawed mirror to the phantom faster-than-light neutrinos. These cases highlight the critical distinction between precision, which measures consistency, and accuracy, which measures truth.

## Key points

- The Hubble Space Telescope was launched in 1990 with a primary mirror polished to a surface roughness of just 9 nanometers.
- The International Vocabulary of Metrology defines accuracy as the closeness of a measured value to the true value of a quantity.
- In September 2011, the OPERA team at the Gran Sasso underground laboratory announced that neutrinos arrived faster than light.
- By February 2012, the OPERA team discovered that a fiber-optic cable carrying GPS signals was not properly seated.

The Hubble Space Telescope was launched in 1990 with a primary mirror polished to a surface roughness of just 9 nanometers, yet it initially sent back blurry images because it was shaped with extreme precision to the wrong specifications. This paradox, where a measurement is repeatable but inaccurate, remains a fundamental challenge in metrology, as seen in the OPERA neutrino experiment and the long-standing discrepancy in the proton's radius.

    Key Insights in This Feature:

- How a mirror polished to nanometer-level smoothness failed in space despite passing multiple tests on Earth.

- Why the International Vocabulary of Metrology distinguishes between precision and accuracy without assigning a numerical value to the latter.

- The case of the faster-than-light neutrinos where a narrow margin of error hid a loose fiber-optic cable.

- The decade-long discrepancy in measuring the radius of the proton.

## What is the difference between accuracy and precision in scientific measurement?

  Scientific metrology distinguishes between these two qualities to prevent systematic errors from being mistaken for truth. According to the International Vocabulary of Metrology (VIM), accuracy is the closeness of a measured value to the true value of a quantity, while precision, also known as consistency, is how close repeated measurements are to one another under the same conditions. One of the more striking notes in the VIM is that accuracy is not a quantity and is not given a numerical value. To quantify accuracy, one would need to know the true value, which is usually the very thing the measurement is trying to discover.

  In the case of the Hubble Space Telescope's mirror, these two qualities diverged catastrophically. The primary testing device used by the contractor, Perkin-Elmer, provided consistent results every time but was calibrated against a flawed template. An investigative board later found that the company relied solely on this single device for both shaping and verification. Two auxiliary tests had actually identified the flaw, including an older-style refractive test. However, because these auxiliary tests were considered less precise than the main instrument, their results were dismissed. The board concluded that the simpler test was more than accurate enough to have caught the deviation if it had been trusted.

## How do systematic errors affect the reported uncertainty of an experiment?

  Systematic errors affect experiments by creating a constant offset that is not reduced by simply repeating the measurement. In the Guide to the Expression of Uncertainty in Measurement (GUM), the &plusmn; symbol indicates uncertainty, representing the dispersion of values that could reasonably be attributed to the quantity. While random errors decrease as more measurements are taken, systematic errors, such as a miscalibrated scale or a slow clock, persist regardless of the sample size.

  In September 2011, the OPERA team at the Gran Sasso underground laboratory announced that neutrinos sent from CERN, 730 kilometers away, arrived 60.7 nanoseconds faster than light would travel the same distance. This measurement carried a narrow uncertainty of 6.9 nanoseconds from statistics and 7.4 nanoseconds from systematic sources. The discrepancy was six times the total margin of error, a result that threatened to overturn Einstein’s theory of special relativity. However, by February 2012, the team discovered two technical failures: a fiber-optic cable carrying GPS signals to the master clock was not properly seated, and a clock oscillator was running fast. These two issues affected the flight time in opposite directions. Once corrected, the result fell to 6.5 nanoseconds, well within the margin of error. The original systematic error calculation had accounted for known sources but could not account for the loose connection.

## Notes and Sources

- Allen, L. et al. (1990). The Hubble Space Telescope Optical Systems Failure Report. NASA, November 1990.

- NASA Science. Hubble's Mirror Flaw. science.nasa.gov

- JCGM 200:2012. International vocabulary of metrology: Basic and general concepts and associated terms (VIM), 3rd edition. BIPM.

- JCGM 100:2008. Evaluation of measurement data: Guide to the expression of uncertainty in measurement (GUM). BIPM.

- OPERA Collaboration, Adam, T. et al. (2012). Measurement of the neutrino velocity with the OPERA detector in the CNGS beam. Journal of High Energy Physics.

- Reich, E. S. (2012). Timing glitches dog neutrino claim. Nature, 483, 17.

- ICARUS Collaboration, Antonello, M. et al. (2012). Measurement of the neutrino velocity with the ICARUS detector at the CNGS beam. Physics Letters B.

- Pohl, R., Antognini, A., Nez, F. et al. (2010). The size of the proton. Nature, 466, 213-216.

- Bezginov, N., Valdez, T., Horbatsch, M., Marsman, A., Vutha, A. C. and Hessels, E. A. (2019). A measurement of the atomic hydrogen Lamb shift and the proton charge radius. Science, 365, 1007-1012.

- Xiong, W., Gasparian, A., Gao, H. et al. (2019). A small proton charge radius from an electron-proton scattering experiment. Nature, 575, 147-150.

- NIST. CODATA 2022 recommended values: proton rms charge radius.

---
Source: AMK News (https://amk.news). Reuse requires attribution and a link to the canonical URL.